Member list completely invisible. Cannot see anyone, not even roles that are displayed separately

(#151) Bug Open: Confirmed community

Summary

image

Steps to reproduce

I don't know exactly when it happened but i was creating roles and assigning permissions and enabled the show separately from others.

Environment (optional)

OS: ArchLinux

Merged posts

These posts were merged into this one. Their comments are now part of the conversation below, marked with where they came from.

Report details

Summary

After creating a new role and enabling the "Show this role separately" toggle in Server Settings → Roles & Permissions, the members list on the right sidebar of public channels disappears or fails to render correctly.
  • This occurs regardless of the permissions assigned to the created role and persists after exiting server settings. The UI appears similar to the attached screenshot, where member entries are not shown.
  • Example:
image ---
  1. Members page fails to show all members.
  • Example:
image

Steps to reproduce

  • Open Server/Community Settings.
  • Navigate to Roles & Permissions.
  • Create a new role (leave permissions at default).
  • Enable the “Show this role” toggle.
  • Exit server settings.
Open any public channel and check the right-side members panel.

Environment (optional)

stable (ab66ad7) web version too (app & web version)

Logs or screenshots (optional)

given

Merged from #290 Members list is empty after enabling "Show this role separately"

RexSystemoriginally by @stemy2 on GitHub

Report details

Summary

Hello, I just created a community, but since i reorganized the members list, it stills empty.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Go to the settings
  2. Check "show this role separately" for at least one role.

Logs or screenshots (optional)

image

Merged from #285 "Show this role separately" breaks Member bar on the server

RexSystemoriginally by @rikkichy on GitHub

Report details

Summary

When user has no roles and in Roles and Permissions at least 2 roles have "Show this role separately" toggle enabled, Member bar breaks. This issue is completely different from issue #121 , because it is permanent and can't be fixed by just reloading the page or CTRL+R.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Make more than 1 role
  2. Enable toggle on both (or more) roles, called "Show this role separately"
  3. See how member bar stopped working correctly
Important
If user has one of these roles, member bar works, but other members just vanish for unknown reason.

Environment (optional)

macOS Tahoe 26.3, Desktop App

Logs or screenshots (optional)

image

Merged from #157 People does not show up in "member" on server

RexSystemoriginally by @Duckisdaebest on GitHub

Report details

Summary

When I added roles to the server I exptected it to show up to the right where it is supposed to show members instead of showing the roles people have it just shows blank, no members no roles just nothing. image

Steps to reproduce

  1. Go to community settings
2, make some roles
  1. Click so the marker on "show this role separately" is ok.
  2. Check if you see members and their roles.

Environment (optional)

OS: Windows 11

Logs or screenshots (optional)

image

22 comments

Sign in with Fluxer to comment and vote.
Comment by Rex
RexSystem 1 vote edited
Status changed from Fixed to Confirmed
Reopened for review.
Comment by Rex
RexSystem 1 vote edited Merged from #77
Status changed from Fixed to Awaiting confirmation
This may be fixed in the current version. If it still happens for you, please say so here.
Comment by @Jiralite
RexSystem 1 vote edited Merged from #77 originally by @Jiralite on GitHub
Please don't prefix your titles with bug, that's what the label is for @cool-aid-man.
Comment by @cool-aid-man
RexSystem 1 vote edited Merged from #77 originally by @cool-aid-man on GitHub
Please don't prefix your titles with bug, that's what the label is for @cool-aid-man.
Oops! so sorry, I didn't check the reply before updating. And sure thing (thought it'd be easier for you guys to review the issues at a glance)
Comment by werhas
werhas 1 vote Merged from #77 originally by @Werhas on GitHub

Summary

After creating a new role and enabling the "Show this role separately" toggle in Server Settings → Roles & Permissions, the members list on the right sidebar of public channels disappears or fails to render correctly.
  • This occurs regardless of the permissions assigned to the created role and persists after exiting server settings. The UI appears similar to the attached screenshot, where member entries are not shown.
  • Example:
image
  1. Members page fails to show all members.
  • Example:
image

Steps to reproduce

  • Open Server/Community Settings.
  • Navigate to Roles & Permissions.
  • Create a new role (leave permissions at default).
  • Enable the “Show this role” toggle.
  • Exit server settings.
Open any public channel and check the right-side members panel.

Environment (optional)

stable (ab66ad7) web version too (app & web version)

Logs or screenshots (optional)

given

Checks

  • [x] I searched for existing issues and didn't find a duplicate.
I think that this is just a general issue with being offline, because when I created a server and changed my status to offline, I disappeared from the members list. I didn't change anything on the server.
Comment by @cool-aid-man
RexSystem 1 vote Merged from #77 originally by @cool-aid-man on GitHub
I think it's something else
  • It persists even with everyone being online.
  • For Example:
image image Everyone here are online, and not offline --- image Another example. Image Credit: damaged#2354 (1471911135213867050)
Comment by werhas
werhas 1 vote Merged from #77 originally by @Werhas on GitHub
I haven't tried it with several people on one server yet, but that's just what I noticed. When I go offline, I stay in the members list as long as I don't switch channels / servers or to favorites and dms, but as soon as I change my status to online, I appear again. When I'm in dms for example and change to offline and go to my server, I also don't appear in the list.
Comment by @Surena0647
RexSystem 1 vote Merged from #157 originally by @Surena0647 on GitHub
I also have issues with the memberlist on the right side. Difference is for me that people do occasionally show up, but wrong. Sometimes they disappear, sometimes they appear correctly, sometimes they appear offline but with a green light as they are in fact online.
Comment by @Duckisdaebest
RexSystem 1 vote Merged from #157 originally by @Duckisdaebest on GitHub
I also have issues with the memberlist on the right side. Difference is for me that people do occasionally show up, but wrong. Sometimes they disappear, sometimes they appear correctly, sometimes they appear offline but with a green light as they are in fact online.
I noticed that after I posted this I also have the same issues you got, but some roles I can give to myself and it will show me in that specific role but it just shows the members as offline 2 but I can only see one offline but there is two
Comment by @IntrinsicClarity
RexSystem 1 vote Merged from #157 originally by @IntrinsicClarity on GitHub
The Members tab seems to only list the most recent members. I don't know if this is a bug or not but I would expect to get a list of all members on the server. Since the members list in the right panel doesn't seem to be working as intended, and seem to only randomly list some members every now and then, there is no real or practical way to know exactly which members currently occupy the server.
Comment by @Duckisdaebest
RexSystem 1 vote Merged from #157 originally by @Duckisdaebest on GitHub
The Members tab seems to only list the most recent members. I don't know if this is a bug or not but I would expect to get a list of all members on the server. Since the members list in the right panel doesn't seem to be working as intended, and seem to only randomly list some members every now and then, there is no real or practical way to know exactly which members currently occupy the server.
Eveyone Seems to have the same issue regarding the list in servers I think we all got same issue but just gets diff outcomes
Comment by @StianNOR
RexSystem 1 vote Merged from #290 originally by @StianNOR on GitHub
I can confirm same issue. i have 4 diffrent roles sometimes 3of 4 shows sometimes 2 of 4 shows. Also not showing offline members, and in member tab no members found.
Comment by @tamasSzentandrasi
RexSystem 1 vote Merged from #290 originally by @tamasSzentandrasi on GitHub
I suspect the members list can render nothing if a group exists but no member rows are assigned to it, because empty groups are skipped entirely in the render path. https://github.com/fluxerapp/fluxer/blob/848269a4d4df7349acfc861ff926b17fe4c4a548/fluxer_app/src/components/channel/ChannelMembers.tsx#L303 So if you end up in a state where the gateway sends/keeps groups (including hoisted-role groups) but the items map doesn’t contain corresponding member rows (or isn’t loaded yet / is partially loaded / is filtered out), the UI drops every group - meaning the whole panel looks empty. Idk, might be better to render the group header even when members aren’t loaded yet (or show skeleton rows), or treat group.count as authoritative while loading. PS. I also had the same issue