Deleting your message upon leaving a server poses issues to conversation history

(#4696) Feature Open: Under consideration accessibility channels community privacy

Thread

Comment by sodiboo
sodiboo 1 vote 1 reply
duplicate of #3454? i like the idea of being able to anonymize messages instead of deleting them. but i don't like the idea that server moderators should be able to force you to only anonymize, never delete. in particular, why are you leaving that server and deleting your messages? probably because you don't appreciate the community anymore. i feel like you should probably be allowed to withdraw the value you have provided, at least on a platform level. see also: Fandom, which doesn't let you delete a wiki even if the entire team of contributors moves to an independent place, and Reddit, which has forcefully replaced the moderation team of subreddits that have protested website admin decisions. in both of these cases, the people in power are kind of holding your contributions hostage, as if they own those contributions. i don't think Fluxer should be providing those kinds of tools to communities. they are already regularly abused.
This poses an issue to servers that are a support group for specific bots, games and other stuff
in the specific case of support groups, there is an endless pain on the internet of seeing forums be replaced by discord servers. because now you have to log in just to read the messages, and they're not nicely structured or indexed in a search engine. Chat apps like Fluxer generally aren't a good place to host documentation and if that's your use case, please use something else. it's for chat. while permanence is nice where all parties consent to it, chat is inherently ephemeral. see also: media attachments on Fluxer having an expiry date. Fluxer's forums may change this? those are vaguely supposed to be publicly webindexable? maybe in that case, it can make sense to have forced-anonymization? but idk what those will look like yet. take note of the fact that Fluxer Feedback is a distinct website and not just a forum channel in Fluxer Labs. this matters for the usability of it as a support forum. way more, in my opinion, than the chance that some people might want to withdraw their contributions.
Comment by snow
snow OP1 vote
Well yes people leave servers because they dislike the server they're also exists a group of people that leave because they are at the server limit and need more servers slots, Just aren't active anymore, or are cutting down the amount of servers they are in. Having a mass delete function encourages people to delete their messages willy nilly. I feel like message deletion is the nuclear option if you really want your messages gone it should be more than just a button push anonymization would be a good middle ground the person cannot be seen by normal people except for moderation. Also yes forms should be a website but maintaining a website is a lot different than maintaining a community. You can be good at maintaining a community but very bad at maintaining software it also serves as a different kind of legal liability if your website gets compromised