Restructuring the Personal Notes menu with the new forum format, to allow more notes to be created & easier to find

(#3818) Feature Open: Under consideration threads-forums-media ui

Current problem

Currently, the Personal Notes button takes us to a tab that looks like a DM with someone. This is fine for quick notes, but as soon as more notes are taken over time it quickly becomes a mess: having to browse individual messages, or use the search bar to find informations about one topic spread across many messages of different dates...

Proposed change

I propose to turn this tab into a forum-like tab: re-using the new forum system is simply perfect in my opinion: we can attach a photo or not to each forum post, give them a name, and keep all our notes in those forums. That way, the Personal Notes feature will look more like a proper note app than a DM, with notes (the forum posts) being able to be sorted from either how old they are, or by last change. Existing notes could be converted easily to a Default forum post to make sure the transition to this system does not destroy the current implementation/content of our current Personal Notes.

Platform

macOS, Windows, Linux, Web, Android, iOS

Additional information

I do not have a visual, but it would litteraly be a re-branded forum tab, of what has been rolled out a few days ago with the forums and media tabs.

2 comments

Sign in with Fluxer to comment and vote.
Comment by sodiboo
I find the "Personal notes" to be mostly useful as a scratch space to paste something to copy on another device; or to quickly play around with markdown and link embeds to see if a message I'm about to send will be formatted how i expect it to. I don't want it to be a forum tab. This actively makes the feature less useful for me, because now i need to go through an extra step before i can paste stuff. For anything actually important (i.e. organized notes) i will not use Fluxer, but rather a purpose built app like Obsidian, which actually has a strong concept of documents and links between those! and those notes are just files on my computer. I don't think Fluxer should encourage using this feature for organized note-taking. It should, however, be powerful enough where there's rarely a need to create a "personal guild" if you DO want to organize your thoughts in Fluxer. To that end, i think what's actually missing is the ability to create threads in personal notes. If you do want to organize multiple messages for distinct chains of thought, threads have it for you! This wouldn't require any kind of migration to a forum channel, and users who want to organize in a forum-like way can just exclusively use the threads view.
Comment by TemperatureSpringbok
i think personal notes should just be a private server, or at least allow multiple channels. it can be just a text channel for people who only need that, but anyone who wants seperate channels or a different kind of channel like a forum can also have that.