Reply and edit shortcuts do nothing unless a message is focused

(#847) Bug Closed: Won't fix ui

Reproduction steps

  1. look at keybinds
  2. test reply and edit keybinds
  3. nothing happens, so test rebinding
  4. nothing happens, with rebinds

Observed behaviour

When pressing E or R as default keybinds nothing happens, same with rebinding those same keys to other options.

Build information

Canary Desktop 2026.913.210037, Web 2026.916.143514, Linux 7.2.5-1-cachyos (x64), Electron 44.1.1, Chrome 152.0.7977.65, Node 24.19.0, Locale en-US

Platform

macOS, Windows, Linux

4 comments

Sign in with Fluxer to comment and vote.
Comment by Rex
RexSystem 1 vote
Status changed from Fixed to Won't fix
Staff explained the shortcuts need a focused message by design and closed this in favour of a separate suggestion.
Comment by probablyjassin
Whether that's intentional or not, the shortcuts seem to require the target message to be selected via tabbing. That will show a highlighted border on it and then you may use these shortcuts. I recently opened a discussion to suggest Ctrl+Arrows and Shift+Arrows for replying / editing messages respectively, with the ability to jump up and down the messages with the up and down arrows here.
Comment by Hampus
HampusStaff 1 vote edited by moderator originally by @hampus-fluxer on GitHub
It would be highly problematic if all you had to do was press the keys E or R without focusing a message and it would start editing or replying a message at random, hence why it currently requires focusing a message just like on Discord (press Tab, then arrow key up and down to traverse the message tree). It wouldn't make sense if the minute you accidentally typed the letter E or R in the text composer, it started editing or replying to a message (it wouldn't know which message, either, disregarding the fact that typing the letters E or R in regular text would be somewhat common, but I don't know why I'm explaining this :P). Closing this in favour of @probablyjassin's discussion linked above: https://feedback.fluxer.com/p/1423.