Feedback on new in-app sound proposals (read the note)

(#4275) Discussion Open: Under consideration
Note
I'm aware manually importing these sounds isn't all that convenient! I'll add this soon: https://feedback.fluxer.com/p/937/import-export-sound-packs. Note that I'm still going to let you switch between the legacy and the new sounds if this were to be implemented, nothing's being forced on anyone, and the sound pack feature would allow people to make their own sounds that people could easily install too.
Hey all! A community member has been working on some new in-app sounds for Fluxer and we'd love your feedback so that they can improve for the better. You can download and set these sounds in the web & desktop app in User Settings > Notifications > Sounds. Here is what each file is for:

53 comments

Sign in with Fluxer to comment and vote.
Comment by Zyro
Zyro 36 votes edited 8 replies
These sounds are a lot nicer than the originals, however I still feel that they suffer from the issue where on smaller speakers with bad low-frequency response (eg; Phones, Computer Monitor Speakers) they can become basically inaudible. Awhile back I ended up creating my own custom sounds for Fluxer and gave them out to close friends of mine. I think if you could use some of the sounds that I've designed as a reference with the above note in mind, something even better could be created in contest:
Edit: If your browser doesn't let you play the sounds, I've attached the full sound pack as a zip so you can browse them externally and even apply them to your client if you wish.
Comment by Hopi
Hopi 5 votes 3 replies
These are nice sounds, they only comment I have is the user joined and user left sounds a little similar, it makes sense for them to be similar but they almost sound the same to me, but thats also just me listening to them back to back so I'm not too sure how it would be in practice
Comment by Zyro
Zyro 10 votes 2 replies
Took your feedback into consideration and rendered out two new revisions of the join and leave sounds. Does this stand out a bit better to your ears?
Comment by dom
dom 3 votes
+1 these are great! i have some hypersensitivity in higher frequencies (harsh metallics usually), which was triggered hearing the ones in the original post, but not these. would love this soft treatment across the board honestly. amazing work, very reminiscent of the 3DS / wii era. thanks!
Comment by sodiboo
sodiboo 2 votes
although semantically it totally makes sense, i think the whoosh in user-moved.wav feels a bit out of place? like, all the other sounds are just beeps and boops and then in there we have email sent. the whoosh sound i heavily associate with email, because some major client (i think Apple Mail) uses a very similar whoosh for sending email.
Comment by finn1sher
I think the proposed sounds are fine in terms of smaller speakers. The most important sounds on mobile are message, call, perhaps join/leave. Many of the voice sounds like mute/deafen, stream viewer, are essentially extra confirmation and don't need to be fully audible on mobile. Push to talk is obviously quiet on purpose. The difference in... audibility? for this sound pack could also be a difference in mixing. Fluxer's proposed sounds could be mixed differently to help make them sound brighter and I'd like that.
Comment by Spax
Spax 19 votes 1 reply
for me personally, I can't help but feel like these sound too generic? it's hard to really design a sound with the intention of it being iconic to the platform its on, but none of these, to me, strike "fluxer" in my heart
Comment by The Blind Bard
I think the are too generic-sounding and don't say "Fluxer" to me. The sounds Fluxer have are terrible, but this is a slight improvement.
Comment by Fullest
Fullest 15 votes
I love incoming-call.wav !! However I don't love the echo-y falloff that many of the notifications have. I prefer a sharper attack and release (though not to the point of harshness) for notifications.
Comment by Zenny
Zenny 9 votes 2 replies
The message-notification.wav sound to me feels not smooth enough, the notes are too disjointed or something. It bothers my mind in some way and I just don't like it. I'm also not really a fan of the echo on many of the voice-channel-related sounds.
Comment by finn1sher
I think it would be wise to use echo for certain voice related sounds to help differentiate them from others, rather than using echo for most sounds.
Comment by Falco
Falco 7 votes edited 1 reply
As a hobby musician and music producer, I like where this is going. This is what I'm thinking:
  1. I think the delay is nice to have, but there's too much of it. I'd recommend maintaining the delay BPM, but reducing how many times it tails off. Additionally, seeing that a lot of people are mentioning the delay, you may also want to pull back the wet signal on the delay. If you want to automate the wet signal, use a compressor and side chain it to the delay so that the delay is compressed appropriately.
  1. I really like the melody for incoming-call.wav with how it's harmonically structured. The chord changes are simple and it doesn't resolve to home until the very end, which feels intentional considering that receiving a notification from a user standpoint is an unresolved notification until the user acknowledges it. I'd recommend keeping the melody and most of the changes; maybe consider not doing vi-I towards the end, and keep the vibe in a major key.
  1. The mute sounds don't feel intentional in that given the note register, it makes the sound feel too bright, which is the opposite of feeling muted. By contrast, the deafen sounds feel intentional. I'd recommend changing the approach for the mute sounds.
In summary, I think the sounds are going in a good direction. Please also consider the rest of the community's comments!
Comment by finn1sher
I also think the sounds are a bit muffled and could be mixed better so they come out a bit sharper and clearer; perhaps even using a slightly brighter mix on mobile and a softer one on desktop. Not to the extent of clearly different sounds (looking at you, facebook messenger sound) but a difference that's only perceptible when played side by side.
Comment by Bloomin' 🌸
Not sure how to feel about the new sounds, they sure have a strong identity but also sound like a retro-nostalgic video game, especially the ringtone What I mean by the video game part is it doesn't sound like a neutral soundscape for a communication app, but it's not bad either
Comment by thematic
thematic 4 votes 1 reply
I thought the user joins voice was a bit too... I know it's supposed to be audible over what ever is going on but, maybe the decay could be quicker? Iow. make it stop sooner.
Comment by Chip
Chip 4 votes
Definite improvement over the current sounds, a lot of these are pretty cool. I think they're totally usable, but I would personally prefer a bit more variation in the sounds. I also think some of them are a bit too bleep-bloopy, the message notification sound is a bit sharp and dragged out. I'm quite fond of the notification sounds in Sable, a Matrix client. I've attached its default message notification sound to this comment. What I do really like out of the new Fluxer sounds are the call-related sounds, especially that ringtone, but also joining/leaving, camera/stream states. The ringtone is pure joy :)
Comment by Hopi
Hopi 3 votes
These sounds are good for something else... I feel they might be a a little too dynamic, they also feel generic in the way of they seem like they are kinda replicating whats been done before, I'm getting heavy skype vibes from these and while it can be nostalgic I do not think they fit fluxer as a modern platfrom, I'm all for changing the current sounds (not that they are bad, they are just basic) I think that it would seem odd to have these with the ui fluxer has and they might feel a bit disconnected from the ui. I can imagine these in 2009-2011 ish still on Windows 7, and I understand people love that style and design and I like it as well but it has a place and I don't think fluxer is that place. If you wanted to make an easter egg in advanced settings at some point that kinda gives fluxer a more "retro" feel these would be great for that, however I'm not too sure about the main style of fluxer that everyone signing up for the first time sees having these as sounds. A suggestion would be to take the current sounds pacing and overall vibe and find a way to make that more unique and distinct for fluxer, one issue with these new ones and the current ones is that they arent intuitive they just feel kinda like sounds that very vaugely represent what is happening, and I feel that sounds should be intuitive and help you understand without looking what is happened or has happend. (eg. you got a message, or are getting a call) I don't know thoes are just my thoughts and I hope they are useful to you.
Comment by sodiboo
sodiboo 3 votes
i really like the incoming call ringtone. i don't have much to say right now about the rest of the sounds . but that ringtone sounds so nice,,,,,,, i love it
Comment by Ringtail
Ringtail 3 votes 1 reply
im a bit late to this thread, but i actually made some UI sounds for fluxer back when it first launched, was intially gonna open it as a pull request to the fluxer repo but couldn't cause it was locked i took heavy inspiration from discord's sounds as my thought with it was that people were already quite familiar with those, and since fluxer itself takes very heavy inspiration from discord, it'd fit right in with making people feel comfortable with the app if anyone has any feedback on them, id be happy to hear it !
Comment by Elwen
Elwen 2 votes
Yeah I particularly like the incoming call sound. That’s one of the main ones I have a problem with other than the voice disconnected one. I like zyros ones a lot
Comment by Tarek
Tarek 2 votes
I added the new message-notification.wav, and I right away feel like this new sound is bit too quiet compared to the old one, the volume is quite low esp if you're playing some game or listening to music in the background.
Comment by Miyano
Miyano 2 votes
All these sounds are excellent, especially the ringtone! Love the theme of them as well.
Comment by wooper
wooper 2 votes
i think some of the sounds fade out for too long or are too echoey. in general they're good, but i think they're also missing a little bit of punch, they feel a bit too gentle. the call sound is sweet :3
Comment by Ziad
Ziad 2 votes
I didn't like the sounds, it feels like it's so basic and there nothing special on it. If you had to replace this sound pack to the new one, please let us choose between the new one and the old one.
Comment by yalpotuA
yalpotuA 2 votes
I feel like the call and ping sounds should be a lot more "potent", i.e. not disappear in the background as easily. Good comparison: Skype's call sound was not only iconic, but also hard to miss. Teams on the other hand has a variant of it that easily disappears in background noise (good for multi-person offices, less good for being able to notice it even when you're in another room).
Comment by 𝕶𝖗𝖎𝖘𝖚𝖍
i'd love for the notification sounds to change, and i ESPECIALLY like the incoming call sound, but i feel like the message notification sound needs a bit more echo
Comment by quince
quince 2 votes
to me the new sounds sound a bit too harsh compared to the current ones
Comment by Ryusei 💫
These sound great! They remind me of Nintendo sound design from the Wii-Wii U/3DS era. Some of them do sound a bit quiet on my laptop with how crappy the speakers are (T480S) but overall, I am a huge fan of the direction. It's so much better than what we have now, and has its own distinct charm compared to current offerings in my opinion. If these end up being canned in favor of something more modern, I think a fun idea would be to have these as a "retro" pack. The idea of multiple sound profiles is really fun imo, and I would definitely use them.
Comment by Comfy_Deer
Comfy_DeerReviewer 2 votes 2 replies
I’ve gotten so used to the current ping sound. I’m hoping the notes or pitch could sound more like how it sounds currently with the new instrumentation.
Comment by finn1sher
finn1sher 1 vote 1 reply
You can always change them yourself...
Comment by Comfy_Deer
Comfy_DeerReviewer 1 vote
That’s true, but it would be nice as a native option. The reworked instrumentation with the original pitch. I’m not really feeling the new sound. But that’s what the feedback site is for isn’t it?
Comment by Fl4il
Fl4il 1 vote
I like all off them (impressive work) except the incoming call one. It sounds a little too much by the end. I'd expect it to be the music to play in the main menu of a legend off zelda type off game. the first ~3 seconds off it would be enough.
Comment by probablyjassin
They did do objectively great work with this, and it's an improvement over lots of the current sounds for sure, although I agree with what Spax says, it's hard to make the sound ""iconic"". Maybe these could be experimented with some more
Comment by What is gaslighting?
I like incoming call! Idk if the lower quality retro audio is very fitting with the modernity of Fluxer though. It also doesn't really feel fitting for an app centered around communication. I don't want to be too harsh, but to me it honestly feels like the sounds belong in a $.99 GameMaker Studio game. I also agree with some of the other comments about reverb being too much.
Comment by Pyroraptor
Pyroraptor 1 vote 2 replies
Sorry for the unrelated comment, but just FYI I have no option to download those on Firefox. I see the three dot menu for each one in Vivaldi, but not Firefox.
Comment by JoJoJux
JoJoJux 3 votes 1 reply
In Firefox you should be able to right-click (desktop) or hold (mobile) on the player and select "Save Audio" (or similar) there.
Comment by Jackuczys
In case of most of these, I vastly prefer the existing sounds to the attached ones. Specifically, (un)mute, (un)deafen, voice join/leave/disconnected, screen share start/stop, camera on/off are all better in the existing client and would not want them to change to the ones attached to this issue. I'm not a fan of current community/direct message notification sounds so maybe the attached ones are better though I'm not entirely convinced. I barely have anyone call me so the incoming call doesn't matter that much to me but I do think I prefer the attached one.
Comment by Dinosaur Gnatalie
For perspective, I'm hard-of-hearing in addition to having permanent tinnitus to contend with, and several of the current sounds offered in the client are still barely detectable with increased volume. I prefer most of the newer versions as well as Zyro's versions for that reason as those suit my specific situation better. Whether notification sounds are suitably Fluxer or unique enough is above my pay grade; I'm just happy to hear them. Options are greatly appreciated! Many thanks to you, Hampus, and all the sound engineering community members.
Comment by yorshex🌻
Kinda eh to me personally First of all, why use the same instrument for (almost) all of them? i think that just makes it hard to tell between different events happening. And im not deep into music theory but i think the notes sound too cheesy for app sounds. But that may be because im not used to smth like that
Comment by Ahryoo
Ahryoo 1 vote
I actually like the current ones that we have in Fluxer alot. Especially that the action and undo are reversed respectively.
Comment by Elwen
Elwen 1 vote
I think everything is genuinely great except the incoming call sound. I like zyros sounds when it comes to voice disconnected. I feel like a lot of the complexity of discords incoming call sound comes from its simple melody just being g d g d e b e b. And it just continues with that. It doesn’t to be complex other than supporting that melody
Comment by astromahdi
i love fluxer and i love this keep cooking yall can't wait for message packs the OP sounds remind me of the first game i ever made in DOS :)
Comment by Pufty
Pufty 1 vote
I like the direction that the OP proposals are going. The only main thing is the notification doesn't feel distinctly interesting yet and the chipper call jingle is interesting, but I wanna hear some more ideas. Maybe one that uses the same 3-4 notes of the start and repeats to just have typical call. Or a jingle that instead of going high past the 3 note repeating structure has fewer notes with, but each note repeats twice/deliberate lag. Proposals in comments felt more typical and idk if that's what you wanna go for, but I do like "carving your own style" approach