Feedback on new in-app sound proposals (read the note)

(#4275) Discussion Open: Under consideration

Thread

Comment by Zyro
Zyro 36 votes edited 1 reply
These sounds are a lot nicer than the originals, however I still feel that they suffer from the issue where on smaller speakers with bad low-frequency response (eg; Phones, Computer Monitor Speakers) they can become basically inaudible. Awhile back I ended up creating my own custom sounds for Fluxer and gave them out to close friends of mine. I think if you could use some of the sounds that I've designed as a reference with the above note in mind, something even better could be created in contest:
Edit: If your browser doesn't let you play the sounds, I've attached the full sound pack as a zip so you can browse them externally and even apply them to your client if you wish.
Comment by finn1sher
I think the proposed sounds are fine in terms of smaller speakers. The most important sounds on mobile are message, call, perhaps join/leave. Many of the voice sounds like mute/deafen, stream viewer, are essentially extra confirmation and don't need to be fully audible on mobile. Push to talk is obviously quiet on purpose. The difference in... audibility? for this sound pack could also be a difference in mixing. Fluxer's proposed sounds could be mixed differently to help make them sound brighter and I'd like that.