Voice Chat: Move Members permission restricted by role hierarchy / configurable move rights

(#3455) Feature Open: Under consideration moderation voice

Current problem

Currently, users who have the permission to move members in voice channels cannot move users who possess the same role or a higher role in the role hierarchy. This makes the move feature very restrictive and impractical for daily server management (e.g., moderators or supporters trying to move peers or higher roles into specific channels).

Proposed change

Allow any user with the "Move Members" permission to move any user between voice channels regardless of role hierarchy, or introduce a configurable option/setting to determine whether role hierarchy limits the ability to move users.

Additional information

Enabling this would make voice management much more flexible for moderators and staff members across different role levels.

2 comments

Sign in with Fluxer to comment and vote.
Comment by sodiboo
sodiboo 2 votes
Yeah, i agree it is silly for "move members" to be hierarchically restricted. It makes it difficult to split a voice channel, among other things. Moving people is not a "moderation" permission; there aren't catastrophic consequences of using it on your superiors. Compare deleting messages. That permission bypasses hierarchy; in a Fluxer guild i'm in with this permission i can even delete messages from the guild owner. Move Members should behave similarly.
Comment by Sebigames
Same issue on a self-hosted instance. Two admins with the same role can’t move or disconnect each other from voice. For reference, Discord doesn’t apply role hierarchy to Move Members / voice disconnect at all, only to kick, ban, timeout, nicknames and role management. Matching that behavior (or making it configurable as suggested) would fix this.