Pingless Mentions

(#1446) Feature Open: Under consideration messaging notifications

Thread

Comment by sodiboo
sodiboo 2 votes 1 reply
came up in conversation in Fluxer HQ and I found this feature request. here's my thoughts (and context) for whether this is a good idea. @I
there should be a way to mention a user without pinging them like <@!userid> or something
@vicky
should there? don't you think it's a nice thing to be made aware when someone, well, literally mentions you?
@sodiboo
well, there's a semantic difference between "i'm talking about this user" and "i need this user's attention". the most compelling example is bots, maybe they want to post some leaderboard about who has sent the most messages. it'd be nice to actually be able to mention those users, without sending them a notification. or, maybe someone asks "hey, who's the lead developer of Fluxer". one could answer by mentioning Hampus, without pinging Hampus. without silent mentions, you have to resort to saying the name; and it's up to the reader to find that name in the member list. obviously, we don't want people taking shit behind others' backs, especially in a public community where that person is. the message could still show up in an "inbox" feed of some kind; but it wouldn't trigger a notification equivalent to "i need you to come look right now because there's an urgent moderation matter".
Comment by vicky
vicky 1 vote
I can get behind this! Having the "silent mention" in the inbox as a way to keep track of them as a "lesser mention" is a nice alternative. Maybe make it part of the notification settings so the users can choose to still get all notifications if they so wish. As for the specific markdown, I would suggest \@username as `` is usually the escape character. Which — to me — makes sense as a "not exactly a mention".