Edit history

Earlier versions of Allow account creation on closed instances with an invite link, newest first.

Current version | Edited by Zero3
Changes
Proposed changeLet community invites created by normal users work as instance invites as well, so the invite link allows account creation instead of showing an error. This could either be the default behaviour, or enabled via instance configuration.Added: It could be worth considering whether this feature should by tied to the existing role/permission system in communities, but that is not relevant for me personally.Added:
Show

Allow account creation on closed instances with an invite link

Current problem

Community members cannot directly invite new members into a closed instance. Opening an invite link created by a normal user currently shows a page with this error message:
Registration is currently closed. Use a registration link from an admin to create an account.
My instance is closed because I do not want random people signing up, but I trust members of the communities on the instance enough to allow them to invite new members to the instance and their communities alike. The current behaviour is particularly problematic for gaming communities that want to invite new people they just met online into their community for voice chat while gaming. In this use case, waiting for instance admin approval is a dealbreaker.

Proposed change

Let community invites created by normal users work as instance invites as well, so the invite link allows account creation instead of showing an error. This could either be the default behaviour, or enabled via instance configuration. It could be worth considering whether this feature should by tied to the existing role/permission system in communities, but that is not relevant for me personally.

Platform

macOS, Windows, Linux, Web, Android, iOS, Self-hosting

Additional information

Edited by Zero3
Changes
PlatformSelf-hostingAdded: Additional informationAdded: Related: https://feedback.fluxer.com/p/3588/allow-admin-registration-links-to-automatically-join-a-speciAdded: Related: https://feedback.fluxer.com/p/1372/let-communities-approve-accounts-registered-through-their-inAdded: Related: https://feedback.fluxer.com/p/4017/allow-users-to-invite-other-usersAdded:
Show

Allow account creation on closed instances with an invite link

Current problem

Community members cannot directly invite new members into a closed instance. Opening an invite link created by a normal user currently shows a page with this error message:
Registration is currently closed. Use a registration link from an admin to create an account.
My instance is closed because I do not want random people signing up, but I trust members of the communities on the instance enough to allow them to invite new members to the instance and their communities alike. The current behaviour is particularly problematic for gaming communities that want to invite new people they just met online into their community for voice chat while gaming. In this use case, waiting for instance admin approval is a dealbreaker.

Proposed change

Let community invites created by normal users work as instance invites as well, so the invite link allows account creation instead of showing an error. This could either be the default behaviour, or enabled via instance configuration.

Platform

macOS, Windows, Linux, Web, Android, iOS, Self-hosting

Additional information

Original by Zero3
Show

Allow account creation on closed instances with an invite link

Current problem

Community members cannot directly invite new members into a closed instance. Opening an invite link created by a normal user currently shows a page with this error message:
Registration is currently closed. Use a registration link from an admin to create an account.
My instance is closed because I do not want random people signing up, but I trust members of the communities on the instance enough to allow them to invite new members to the instance and their communities alike. The current behaviour is particularly problematic for gaming communities that want to invite new people they just met online into their community for voice chat while gaming. In this use case, waiting for instance admin approval is a dealbreaker.

Proposed change

Let community invites created by normal users work as instance invites as well, so the invite link allows account creation instead of showing an error. This could either be the default behaviour, or enabled via instance configuration.

Platform

macOS, Windows, Linux, Web, Android, iOS, Self-hosting