AFK channels should silence people without denying Speak

(#4790) Feature Open: Under consideration self-hosting voice

Current problem

The only channel setting that stops people talking is denying Speak. That denial is what leaves them self-muted after they leave. Other voice permissions do not keep a channel quiet, checked on release 2026.1028.163925:
  • Denying Use Voice Activity does nothing. The client computes canUseVad and never uses it to require push-to-talk. Same as #3987.
  • Mute Members and Deafen Members are the right to server-mute or server-deafen a person. They are checked for the whole community, not per channel, and a server mute follows the person into every other channel. They cannot undo it themselves.
  • A user limit, or denying Connect, does not stop talking. Denying Connect would also block the idle move, because the server makes no AFK exception.
  • There is no stage channel and no switch that means the AFK channel is silent.
Push-to-talk is each person's own setting.

Proposed change

While someone is in the AFK channel, silence them without writing that into their saved self-mute, and put their previous mute back when they leave. People in the AFK channel should not be able to talk to each other, and leaving it should leave their mute as it was before.

Platform

Linux, Web, Self-hosting

Additional information

Choosing the channel as the AFK channel today only stores the channel id and the idle timeout. The silence has to be a separate permission override, and that override is the bug.

Comments

Sign in with Fluxer to comment and vote.

No comments yet.