Reproduction steps
- Deny Speak for @everyone on a voice channel, and set that channel as the AFK channel.
- Join a different voice channel while unmuted.
- Get moved into the AFK channel, or join the Speak-denied channel yourself.
- Move back to a voice channel where Speak is allowed.
Expected behaviour
You are unmuted, the same as before the move. A mute the channel forced on you does not become your saved mute.
Actual behaviour
You are self-muted. Clicking unmute clears it, but the mute was saved as your own setting, so it is what the client sends the next time you join.
This showed up as people staying muted after the AFK channel. Those AFK channels denied Speak for @everyone. I have not caught it again on a live call since that denial was removed. The path is from the client source, and it is unchanged between release 2026.1028.163925 and commit f1cba64e (2026-11-09).
- On join, if Speak is denied, the client sends self_mute true no matter what the user had set. applyVoiceSpeakPermissionToSelfMute in VoiceChannelConnector.tsx, and syncSpeakPermissionState in VoiceEngineV2AppPermissionAdapter.ts.
- The gateway echoes the voice state. The client copies self_mute into local state. LocalVoiceState.syncConnectionState in MediaEngineFacade.ts.
- syncConnectionState in LocalVoiceStateMachine.ts ends in persistMuteAndDeafenDefaults, so the forced mute is written as the user's own mute preference.
- On the next channel, where Speak is allowed, the client sends that saved mute. Nothing puts back the value from before.
Build information
Self-hosted web client, release 2026.1028.163925. Source read at f1cba64e (2026-11-09). This path has no functional change since that release.
Platform
Linux, Web, Self-hosting
Evidence
The trigger was on the instance before the Speak denial was removed: the AFK channels denied Speak for @everyone, with a 30 minute idle timeout. Fluxer does not add that override when a channel is chosen as AFK. The server only stores the channel id and the timeout, so the denial had been set by hand.
Workaround that stops it: remove the Speak denial, then click unmute once. People in the AFK channel can then hear each other. Clicking unmute after you leave also clears a mute that already stuck.
Proper fix: do not copy a mute that was forced by a missing Speak permission into the saved preference. Restore the user's previous mute when they leave.
Not #254. There the mic still looks unmuted while you are in the channel that denies Speak.
1 comment
Comment by Rex