Moderation notices should show the removed content and review context

(#4761) Feature Open: Under consideration moderation

Current problem

When Fluxer removes a message under a rule like "Threats of violence", the notice doesn't show the message. Mine gave the channel and a timestamp, so I can only guess which message it meant. It also doesn't say whether the reviewer looked at the conversation around it, what the report claimed, or what the reviewer found that broke the rule. A message that reads as a threat on its own can be a joke in context. Right now the user can't tell whether context was checked.

Proposed change

Include in the notice:
  • The removed content: the message text, or for attachments the file name and type, plus the community, channel and time. If the message was edited, show the version the reviewer saw. If the text can't be shown, give an ID the user can look up.
  • The context reviewed: whether the reviewer saw the surrounding messages, roughly how many before and after, and the message it replied to if any. Limit this to what the user could already see in that channel.
  • The report: its category, without the reporter's identity.
  • The reasoning: which rule the reviewer applied and which part of the content broke it. If the reviewer decided on a different rule than the one reported, say so.
  • The outcome: what action was taken (removal, warning, restriction) and whether it counts toward future enforcement.
For severe content such as CSAM, don't reproduce or link it. Describe the type of content, the rule it broke, and where and when it was posted. Also add an in-app place to review these decisions, not only an email. It should:
  • List every moderation decision on the account, with the full notice details above
  • Show the appeal deadline and let the user appeal from there instead of replying to an email
  • Show the appeal status and outcome once a reviewer has decided
  • Notify the user in the app when a decision or an appeal result comes in
Email can stay as a notification, but the app should be where the full record lives, since an email can be lost, deleted or missed.

Comments

Sign in with Fluxer to comment and vote.

No comments yet.