Allow bulk-deletion of my messages in communities I am no longer part of

(#3545) Feature Closed: Shipped messaging privacy

9 votes Locked

Thread

Comment by WolfSkin
WolfSkin 1 vote edited 1 reply
Honestly, I don't see a way to enforce your messages being deleted from somewhere that someone else controls, once you have left. Particularly once federation comes around, there is nothing stopping someone from modifying their server to not respect bulk deletion calls for a community you're in after all, so it's moot from that point onwards. Before that point (i.e. you are about to leave but aren't out of the community yet), sure, I think bulk deletion is probably a decent feature to support, but imho we have to draw the line at not being able to affect the contents of a community once you are no longer part of it.
Comment by glyph
glyph OP3 votes
I think we should not focus too much on potentially hostile instances. Yeah, a potentially hostile instance could ignore those requests. It could also ignore bulk deletion requests while you're still in the server, or ignore standard message deletion as well. The focus should be on protocol-compliant instances and in general I'd assume that the community owners and the instance owners are separate groups and the latter don't have any interest in not honoring deletion requests. (A wholly hostile instance that doesn't honor deletion requests would also be in violation of the GDPR, so I think we can generally assume that most instances won't behave this way)