Receiving a notification makes the user appear online briefly, despite not having opened the app

(#3510) Bug Closed: Fixed Priority: P2 messaging mobile notifications

Reproduction steps

  1. Fully close the app
  2. An independent user can observe the gray / "offline" indicator on your profile
  3. Have the independent user message you, and do not interact with the notification and keep the app closed

Observed behaviour

To the independent user, your profile switches to the green phone / "online (on mobile)" indicator, right as you receive the notification. After 10-30s, your profile goes back to offline. Note that I used to be able to reproduce this on my own devices with an alt account; now only with a second person and their account. The bug occurs in both directions between us. Lmk if this is actually an API issue I should report on the desktop side of things.

Build information

Version 2026.10.100, Beta 2, Channel Beta, Build 2591, Android 16 (arm64), Device samsung SM-S918B, Locale en-GB, Push fcm, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5

Platform

macOS, Windows, Linux, Web, Android, Self-hosting

Evidence

Details

Expected behaviour Your status stays "offline"
  1. bizo changed the status from Needs triage to Confirmed

7 comments

Sign in with Fluxer to comment and vote.
Comment by Rex
RexSystem 1 vote
Status changed from Confirmed to Fixed
Fixed in mobile beta 5 and later. A notification that wakes the app in the background doesn't make you show as online, and a tester confirmed it on beta 7.
Comment by Eyeflame
EyeflameReviewer 1 vote
Can't reproduce CNR; Version 2026.10.100, Beta 2, Channel Beta, Build 591, Android 13 (arm64), Device Xiaomi 21061110AG, Locale en-US, Push fcm, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5
Comment by bizo
bizoReviewer 1 vote
Can reproduce Seen this happen many times especially in group DM - Version 2026.10.100, Beta 2, Channel Beta, Build 84, iOS 26.6 (arm64), Device iPhone13,1, Locale en-GB, Push apns, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5
Comment by Dinosaur Gnatalie
Can reproduce CR - Retested; previously marked this CNR. Version 2026.10.100, Beta 2, Channel Beta, Build 2591, Android 16 (arm64), Device Google Pixel 9 Pro, Locale en-US, Push fcm, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5
Comment by Mizarc
MizarcMod 1 vote
Can reproduce I have one user in my group that shows up as online (on mobile) any time I send a message. They do not have Fluxer open on their mobile device when it happens. - Version 2026.09.100, Beta 3, Channel Beta, Build 2530, Android 17 (arm64), Device Google Pixel 7, Locale en-AU, Push fcm, Flutter 3.47.5, Dart 3.13.4
Comment by probablyjassin
On top of this [Desktop], I also just discovered that when this bug occurs, the user, despite erroneously being switched to the "online (on mobile)" status indicator, they don't actually appear online in the sidebar communities they are members of. Clicking on these entries still shows their wrong online indicator however. Also: If the user does actually come online during this wrong state, the online on mobile indicator of course remains, but they still aren't moved to the "Online" section in said communities. I've just had a case where I message someone, they haven't opened the app yet, get the online indicator but are grouped as offline in the community, and then come online a couple seconds later, reply to my message etc, and still stay grouped as offline in the community we are both part of. Canary Desktop 2026.1009.45608, Web 2026.1011.125152, Linux 7.2.9-2-cachyos (x64), Electron 44.4.1, Chrome 152.0.7977.78, Node 24.21.0, Locale en-US My instance: Canary Web 2026.1011.135948, Linux (x64), Firefox 157.0, Locale en-US
Comment by probablyjassin
Will do some more testing later in the day but at first glance I can't reproduce anymore as of the new beta 🎉 (2026.10.100-beta.7) Edit: It's fixed!