[Regression?] Notifications already read while app is open received when the app is closed ([#277](<https://github.com/fluxerapp/flutter_client/issues/277>))

(#3446) Bug Closed: Fixed mobile

Reproduction steps

  1. Use the App
  2. Receive new messages in the currently open chat (get read instantly)
  3. Close the app immediately

Observed behaviour

Messages that were already read a couple seconds ago trigger notifications when closing the app shortly after

Build information

Version 2026.10.100, Beta 1, Channel Beta, Build 576, Android 16 (arm64), Device samsung SM-S921B, Locale en-US, Push fcm, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5

Platform

Android

Details

Expected behaviour Messages that were already read a couple seconds ago shouldn't trigger notifications when closing the app shortly after
  1. Rex changed the status from Needs triage to Confirmed
  2. Tarek changed the status from Awaiting confirmation to Fixed
  1. The pull request flutter_client#974 mentions this post Merged
  2. The pull request flutter_client#979 mentions this post Merged

Merged posts

These posts were merged into this one. Their comments are now part of the conversation below, marked with where they came from.

Report details

Reproduction steps

  1. Use the App
  2. Receive new messages in the currently open chat (get read instantly)
  3. Close the app immediately

Observed behaviour

Messages that were already read a couple seconds ago trigger notifications when closing the app shortly after Expected behaviour Messages that were already read a couple seconds ago shouldn't trigger notifications when closing the app shortly after

Build information

Version 2026.10.100, Beta 1, Channel Beta, Build 576, Android 16 (arm64), Device samsung SM-S921B, Locale en-US, Push fcm, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5

Platform

Android, iOS

Details

Stances
Approvals
  • CR - Retested; previously marked this CNR. - Version 2026.10.100, Beta 2, Channel Beta, Build 2591, Android 16 (arm64), Device Google Pixel 9 Pro, Locale en-US, Push fcm, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5
  • Version 2026.10.100, Beta 2, Channel Beta, Build 591, Android 16 (arm64), Device realme RMX5108, Locale en-IN, Push fcm, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5
  • CR; It's not consistent, but it happens occasionally - Version 2026.10.100, Beta 2, Channel Beta, Build 591, Android 13 (arm64), Device Xiaomi 21061110AG, Locale en-US, Push fcm, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5
Denials
  • Not had this happen to me - Version 2026.10.100, Beta 2, Channel Beta, Build 84, iOS 26.6 (arm64), Device iPhone13,1, Locale en-GB, Push apns, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5
--- Reported: #1821

5 comments

Sign in with Fluxer to comment and vote.
Comment by Rex
RexSystem 1 vote
Status changed from Confirmed to Awaiting confirmation
Fixed in mobile beta 7 and later. Channels you're reading are marked as read as new messages come in, and you shouldn't get notifications for them after you close the app. On iOS, getting the latest TestFlight build may not work right now if you weren't already up to date before October 29, when TestFlight stopped working for Fluxer because of a bug on Apple's side. Please check on the latest beta and let us know.
Comment by Microsoft® Windows™ XP
Can reproduce Version 2026.10.100, Beta 2, Channel Beta, Build 591, Android 16 (arm64), Device realme RMX5108, Locale en-IN, Push fcm, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5
Comment by bizo
bizoReviewer 1 vote
Moderator note Not had this happen to me - Version 2026.10.100, Beta 2, Channel Beta, Build 84, iOS 26.6 (arm64), Device iPhone13,1, Locale en-GB, Push apns, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5
Comment by Eyeflame
EyeflameReviewer 1 vote
Can reproduce CR; It's not consistent, but it happens occasionally - Version 2026.10.100, Beta 2, Channel Beta, Build 591, Android 13 (arm64), Device Xiaomi 21061110AG, Locale en-US, Push fcm, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5
Comment by Dinosaur Gnatalie
Can reproduce CR - Retested; previously marked this CNR. - Version 2026.10.100, Beta 2, Channel Beta, Build 2591, Android 16 (arm64), Device Google Pixel 9 Pro, Locale en-US, Push fcm, Flutter 3.47.6, Dart 3.13.5