Speaking in a voice channel/voice call in the Linux desktop app causes the volume of my mic to lower by itself

(#344) Bug Closed: Fixed desktop voice

Summary

When I speak in a voice channel unmuted in the Linux desktop app, the volume of my microphone lowers by itself DE-wide without my input. I expect it to not lower. This only happens in the desktop app, not the web version.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Unmute your microphone, if it is muted.
  2. Enter a voice channel or voice call.
  3. Make noises for a bit.

Environment (optional)

  • OS: Pop!_OS 24.04 LTS
  • Desktop Environment: COSMIC
  • Browser (when I use the web version): Zen Browser

Logs or screenshots (optional)

556563774-d6962f6e-df64-43af-89c0-f14ead8af017.mp4

9 comments

Sign in with Fluxer to comment and vote.
Comment by Rex
RexSystem 1 vote edited
Status changed from Fixed to Awaiting confirmation
This may be fixed in the current version. If it still happens for you, please say so here.
Comment by Rex
RexSystem 1 vote
Status changed from Awaiting confirmation to Fixed
Imported from GitHub, fix shipped. Closed in bulk.
Comment by @powerofthe69
RexSystem 1 vote originally by @powerofthe69 on GitHub
Isn't this exactly how auto-gain works? I always turn that off in Vesktop, Discord, and even in Fluxer because auto-gain is trash. At least on Linux.
Comment by @lexifuzzpup
RexSystem 1 vote originally by @lexifuzzpup on GitHub
This feature bothers me so much. I've never found a way to disable it; for me, gain control options do nothing. I've had to write a cron job to set all microphone levels back to 80% every 30 seconds so it doesn't creep down to inaudible levels.
Comment by @powerofthe69
RexSystem 1 vote originally by @powerofthe69 on GitHub
This feature bothers me so much. I've never found a way to disable it; for me, gain control options do nothing. I've had to write a cron job to set all microphone levels back to 80% every 30 seconds so it doesn't creep down to inaudible levels.
Assuming it's not been deprecated, Electron should have a launch flag like --disable-features=WebRtcAllowInputVolumeAdjustment to disable it that you could try
Comment by @AuTune
RexSystem 1 vote originally by @AuTune on GitHub
I have auto gain disabled in Fluxer settings, works fine for me. Both on web and desktop. Using CachyOS.
Comment by @nlutterman
RexSystem 1 vote originally by @nlutterman on GitHub
Isn't this exactly how auto-gain works? I always turn that off in Vesktop, Discord, and even in Fluxer because auto-gain is trash. At least on Linux.
Most other voice applications I've used handle autogain internally, like as an effect applied on a copy of the audio source. In my personal opinion, the application should not have an effect on a system-level configuration. If it's a setting available inside of Fluxer, I would expect it to only affect Fluxer.
Comment by @powerofthe69
RexSystem 1 vote originally by @powerofthe69 on GitHub
Most other voice applications I've used handle autogain internally, like as an effect applied on a copy of the audio source.
If these other applications that you're thinking of are not using WebRTC, then that would be why. As I mentioned, this is a known behavior for WebRTC applications like Discord and Fluxer when using automatic gain control. It automatically lowers the microphone volume at the system-level on both Windows and Linux. I don't have a Mac, but I'd assume it acts the same unless Mac doesn't allow access to its system audio API in this way. https://wiki.robotz.com/index.php?title=WebRTC_Automatic_Gain_Control Edit: formatting
Comment by @R3alCl0ud
RexSystem 1 vote originally by @R3alCl0ud on GitHub
Another solution for this since a lot of chromium/electron apps like to do this is to set the permissions to read only on the pipewire side.

Steps:

  1. navigate to ~/.config/wireplumber
  2. if not present create a directory named wireplumber.conf.d
  3. create a new file in the wireplumber.conf.d directory no-fluxer-auto-gain.conf and paste the following:
    access.rules = [
        {
            matches = [
                { application.process.binary = "fluxer" }, # add more lines for every app you want to have read only permissions
            ]
            actions = {
                update-props = {
                    default_permissions = "rx"
                }
            }
        }
    ]
  1. Log out and log back into to your DE or restart your PC.