This "guest access" should also extend to people with accounts.
Again, with the gaming use case, very recently i've been in a situation where me and a group were in a voice call (on Discord, forgive me!) playing an online game with one random stranger. We thought their vibe was cool, so we wanted to chat on Discord and party up for the next game or two. But we didn't want to add this person to our friend group's guild without further screening. So, we used a group chat, moved the call there, and invited the person to the group chat.
It would be cool if we could invite them as a guest temporarily to the call session (or for an event organized in a private server) and they could "participate" temporarily in our guild's activities, without actually being a permanent member at any point in time.
A different use case for this is game development. I'm a game developer. I organize with my devbestie in a discord guild. At one point, we wanted to invite a user to test something one-off. This led to restructuring all the existing internal chats into being locked behind roles, and we had to create a separate "public" area of the guild where our playtester could chat and join a call. It would be nice to instead allow this user to join our call that one time, without granting access to the rest of the otherwise-private guild, because at the end of the day it's an internal guild for development activities and not for public use.
permission-wise, I'm imagining that a "guest" is someone who doesn't inherit anything from the @everyone role (whether it be an ephemeral account or not). and while they're present, they would instead be granted access to channels with per-account overrides. and "letting a guest stay" would be equivalent to assigning them the @everyone role. anyone without @everyone would be prominently marked with a GUEST tag near their name, which potentially indicates they haven't read the rules (?) (but that's okay, an admin invited them and can keep them in line)
this idea of "someone without @everyone permissions" feels similar to a different setup I've done with a verification bot on discord. in order to not make the channel list filled with locks (not very aesthetic!), i had a bot automatically assign an "Unverified" role to all new members, which would remove "read messages" from all other channels. then, they'd have to go through our onboarding (linking with the main service this community was attached to), and only then would they be allowed to see channels from @everyone. it would also be nice if people who never verified were not there permanently to begin with; what i really want for this use case is to Only create "guest invite" links to this community, and my bot would be in charge of assigning @everyone to users who completed our custom onboarding.
Thread
Comment by sodiboo
@everyonerole (whether it be an ephemeral account or not). and while they're present, they would instead be granted access to channels with per-account overrides. and "letting a guest stay" would be equivalent to assigning them the@everyonerole. anyone without@everyonewould be prominently marked with a GUEST tag near their name, which potentially indicates they haven't read the rules (?) (but that's okay, an admin invited them and can keep them in line) this idea of "someone without@everyonepermissions" feels similar to a different setup I've done with a verification bot on discord. in order to not make the channel list filled with locks (not very aesthetic!), i had a bot automatically assign an "Unverified" role to all new members, which would remove "read messages" from all other channels. then, they'd have to go through our onboarding (linking with the main service this community was attached to), and only then would they be allowed to see channels from@everyone. it would also be nice if people who never verified were not there permanently to begin with; what i really want for this use case is to Only create "guest invite" links to this community, and my bot would be in charge of assigning@everyoneto users who completed our custom onboarding.