Deleted users are not removed from guild's ban list

(#1301) Bug Closed: Fixed community moderation

Summary

(Platform?-)Banned users (or otherwise deleted users) are not removed from a guild's ban list. I moderate a community of >1000 members and we had to manually remove every DeletedUser#0000 entry that accumulated over time from our ban list. Deleted users should be automatically removed from the guild's ban list.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Have user get their account deleted
  2. Open your guild's ban list
  3. See DeletedUser#0000

Environment

Canary Web 2026.605.11941, Linux (x64), Firefox 152.0, Locale fr

Logs or screenshots

image
  1. Rex changed the status from Shipped to Fixed

3 comments

Sign in with Fluxer to comment and vote.
Comment by Rex
RexSystem 1 vote
Official response
Staff confirmed deleted users are now removed from community ban lists. This status matches the bug kind.
Comment by SuperSajuuk
SuperSajuuk 1 vote originally by @SuperSajuuk on GitHub
Accounts which are banned from a community are banned by the IP address used at the same the ban was issued, and the email address on their account. Automatically revoking a ban on a community because the users' account was deleted is likely to result in an obvious abuse pattern whereby:
  • Bad actor makes a throwaway account.
  • The actor in question joins your community and spams it with TOS violating content.
  • They get banned from your community by a mod or admin.
  • The bad actor proceeds to delete their account (or gets banned by Fluxer).
  • Waits until the account is fully deleted.
  • Makes a new account and continues.
A better solution here is to simply not display Deleted Users in the ban list (but not remove the ban in question), maintaining security from trolls spamming with alts. In this case, a count of hidden ban entries should be displayed, something like "(count) banned accounts are hidden from this list because they no longer refer to a valid user account, however their accounts are still banned from your community." Ultimately this isn't a bug and is a feature request, as the list is behaving as intended (in parity to Discord's ban list).
Comment by Hampus
HampusStaff 1 vote originally by @hampus-fluxer on GitHub
For some time now, deleted users have been removed from the ban list in communities, so this should be solved (though not applied retroactively).