Comment history
Versions of a comment on SMS Authentication on Fluxer (example: fluxer bot will send messages to your phone number to verify the code and pasting in)), newest first.
Current version | Edited by sodiboo
Changes
SMS verification is insecure due to SIM hijacking (a specific kind of social engineering attack, which email is less susceptible to) and because SMS can happen over insecure protocols that are vulnerable to MITM (a technical attack, which email is also less susceptible to).Removed: Why do you want SMS to be an acceptable fallback for a lost authenticator? Can't you just reset your password through email? That's the de-facto standard way to recover account login credentials on every web service. Added: Why do you want SMS to be an acceptable fallback for a lost authenticator? Can't you just reset your password through email? That's the de-facto standard way to recover account login credentials on every web service. Or save your recovery codes somewhere? Or just don't use 2FA if you think you will lose your authenticator and don't want 2FA to be mandatory? the *point* of an authenticator is that if you lose it, you get locked out. don't use it if you don't want that behavior.SMS is expensive to send, so it's impractical to implement. Emails are free to send. Phone numbers are easy to lose access to; people change their number all the time. Email addresses, less so. Phone numbers are also more often tied to a legal identity than an email address. Collecting a phone number is in many cases functionally equivalent to collecting an ID. This makes SMS verification a notable privacy concern.
Show
SMS verification is insecure due to SIM hijacking (a specific kind of social engineering attack, which email is less susceptible to) and because SMS can happen over insecure protocols that are vulnerable to MITM (a technical attack, which email is also less susceptible to).
Why do you want SMS to be an acceptable fallback for a lost authenticator? Can't you just reset your password through email? That's the de-facto standard way to recover account login credentials on every web service. Or save your recovery codes somewhere? Or just don't use 2FA if you think you will lose your authenticator and don't want 2FA to be mandatory? the point of an authenticator is that if you lose it, you get locked out. don't use it if you don't want that behavior.
SMS is expensive to send, so it's impractical to implement. Emails are free to send. Phone numbers are easy to lose access to; people change their number all the time. Email addresses, less so. Phone numbers are also more often tied to a legal identity than an email address. Collecting a phone number is in many cases functionally equivalent to collecting an ID. This makes SMS verification a notable privacy concern.
Edited by sodiboo
Changes
Removed: SMS verification is insecure due to SIM hijacking (a specific kind of social engineering attack, which email is less susceptible to) and because SMS can happen over insecure protocols (a technical attack, which email is also less susceptible to).Added: SMS verification is insecure due to SIM hijacking (a specific kind of social engineering attack, which email is less susceptible to) and because SMS can happen over insecure protocols that are vulnerable to MITM (a technical attack, which email is also less susceptible to).Why do you want SMS to be an acceptable fallback for a lost authenticator? Can't you just reset your password through email? That's the de-facto standard way to recover account login credentials on every web service.
Show
SMS verification is insecure due to SIM hijacking (a specific kind of social engineering attack, which email is less susceptible to) and because SMS can happen over insecure protocols that are vulnerable to MITM (a technical attack, which email is also less susceptible to).
Why do you want SMS to be an acceptable fallback for a lost authenticator? Can't you just reset your password through email? That's the de-facto standard way to recover account login credentials on every web service.
SMS is expensive to send, so it's impractical to implement. Emails are free to send. Phone numbers are easy to lose access to; people change their number all the time. Email addresses, less so. Phone numbers are also more often tied to a legal identity than an email address. Collecting a phone number is in many cases functionally equivalent to collecting an ID. This makes SMS verification a notable privacy concern.
Original by sodiboo
Show
SMS verification is insecure due to SIM hijacking (a specific kind of social engineering attack, which email is less susceptible to) and because SMS can happen over insecure protocols (a technical attack, which email is also less susceptible to).
Why do you want SMS to be an acceptable fallback for a lost authenticator? Can't you just reset your password through email? That's the de-facto standard way to recover account login credentials on every web service.
SMS is expensive to send, so it's impractical to implement. Emails are free to send. Phone numbers are easy to lose access to; people change their number all the time. Email addresses, less so. Phone numbers are also more often tied to a legal identity than an email address. Collecting a phone number is in many cases functionally equivalent to collecting an ID. This makes SMS verification a notable privacy concern.